“Sleepy Hollow” returns and at this point I’m not sure what to think about it. Suffice to say, I was impressed with most of the character beats this episode though, which I think is something “Sleepy Hollow” has always excelled at. Now the question is if they know what they’re doing since they ended part of the reason for the show’s existence last episode (preventing Moloch’s Apocalypse). I like the new character introduced though, and I’ll get into him later in the review.
“Paradise Lost” was directed by Russell Fine and written by M. Raven Metzner.
The premise of the episode is that we pick up where we left off. Henry Parish, the Horseman of War is missing and the Apocalypse has been averted. We skip forward 6 weeks to see that Katrina and the Headless Horseman Abraham are developing their relationship as she tries to save him and a new character arrives, Orion who was trapped in purgatory and is hunting down demons like Ichabod and Abbie. But all is not as it appears to be as we soon learn he holds other purposes for his vendetta against the Horseman of Death.
The Pros: Jenny Mills – She has a small role in this as helping find the demons and where they are located as well as organizing a night on the town, which is all wasted as we have Nick Hawley arrive and try to get back with her. I hate that this guy is still around on the show.
Ichabod Crane – Ichabod is great again as usual as Abbie is trying to help him integrate into a world where he no longer has to be a hunter. We see that hunting is his escape from not having to deal with his relationship with Katrina who is spending lots of time with Abraham and they both realize that they need to redefine their relationship in the end when Katrina saving Abraham is shown to be the right thing when Orion wants only destruction of all evil in humanity by any means necessary. He grows a lot in this episode.
Abbie Mills – Abbie is taken in by Orion when he appears and he gives her a charm in which she can use to call on him. They are both soldiers who have lost people to the war against Evil but Abbie soon learns that she is no zealot and works with Ichabod to save Abraham when she learns of Orion’s plans.
Orion – This angel is awesome and I hope we see more of him. He is the Angel of Death and whenever a city was destroyed in the past for being “sinful” he was the angel to do it. This is why he was locked in purgatory. He loses his weapon but is still a threat as gunshots and spirit weapons had no effect on him. Can’t wait to see where they take this character and explore Angels. Angels were one of the few good things about “Supernatural” and “Sleepy Hollow” generally has better writers.
Abraham / The Headless Horseman / The Horseman of Death – This guy is still just as prideful and angry, but like Illidan in Warcraft III he seems to genuinely love Katrina so much so that he will wait until she finds a way to make him human again and no longer the Horseman of Death. This shows depth but I still hope he stays bad, just like Henry Parish. War and Death are the best parts of this show since Moloch was shown to be a waste and I hope they aren’t wasted in turn. Also it was great that he killed Orion the first time around and almost did so again. This guy is someone you don’t mess with in a fight.
Okay: Katrina Crane – Katrina isn’t bad in this and we can see that guilt motivates her relationship with Abraham. She actually had a little depth this episode but I don’t really consider her good and she and Ichabod are still a bit naive when it comes to the Horsemen.
Detective Irving – Is alive? Maybe it was from Death’s power being released when Orion’s weapon got destroyed. Curious where this will go. I’m glad he’s back but that was sudden. God, Moloch was useless as a baddie.
The Cons: Nick Hawley – Guy is like nails on the chalkboard in every scene he is in. Can one of the demons or creatures out there just kill him already? He lends nothing to the script and is a contrived romantic interest.
This was a good start, and I’m hoping we see things get big again. I would not mine seeing more Heavenly Hosts and the Devil and have them go “Supernatural” in “Sleepy Hollow” fashion. I just don’t want them bogged down in Monster of the Week and trying to redeem everyone. Part of what makes Henry Parish and Abraham great is that they are complex villains, but still villains. If that is lost I doubt I will watch onward. This show needs good antagonists of which they are.
Final Score: 9 / 10. Solid start.