This was a very fun “Sleepy Hollow” episode that managed to give us an interesting glimpse into some characters, as well as setting up more of what is to come. We get to know more about Detective Irving’s situation and even hints that the Witnesses still have a greater role to play.
“What Lies Beneath” was directed by Dwight Little and written by Damian Kindler who also wrote the original story with Philip Iscove.
The premise involves three workers finding a secret room and getting kidnapped by Reavers leading Abbie and Ichabod to mount a rescue while dealing with one of the brothers of the kidnapped who is a journalist seeking the truth. Around the same time Irving asks Jenny for help leading to them breaking into Police Headquarters before he reveals his purpose.
The Pros: Hologram Jefferson – Thomas Jefferson is in this, or at least the echo is any way. He is created by witchcraft and science to hold all of Jefferson’s memories and is there to help guide the Witnesses in what they need to know. Sadly he is also on a Reaver’s nest and the only way to stop the Reaver’s is to destroy his power source, which in the end he does as he apologizes for Ichabod for slighting him and that he consider’s Ichabod a Founding Father.
Detective Irving – Irving get’s a Hellfire charm that helps him become aware enough long enough to get Jenny the data his family needs to get out of town. He has no memory of what his evil side has done but he is aware his soul is broken and corrupted. I think he knows he’ll be fighting Ichabod and co. by the end of the season.
Jenny – Jenny holds Irving accountable and finds him. It’s actually pretty cool that she listens and it makes sense she understands given how often she’s dealt with her own darker side and demons growing up.
Ichabod and Abbie – These two do a great job dealing with the Reavers and manage to save 2 of the workers. Abbie’s arc involves her keeping the work secret but promising the truth eventually to Calvin (whose brother was captured) and they begin to build a respectful relationship. Ichabod and Jefferson heal up their relationship and stop the Reavers as they were always supposed to be about protection and people over knowledge when it came down to action.
Okay: Henry Parish and Katrina – Katrina has a “dream” that the episode implies actually happened where Parish said her and the magic users will get revenge that his purpose is now for their ascension. She’s afraid of him (for good reason) and what he’ll use her blood for remains to be seen. The scene could have been more threatening, it was presented kind of awkwardly.
I enjoyed this episode a lot and would consider it good but not great. The Katrina issue is still an issue in regards to her being the victim more often than not and I hope they don’t mess up the role of Calvin the journalist. There is promise again, lets just hope “Sleepy Hollow” doesn’t mess things up.
Final Score: 8 / 10.