I’m really liking “Star Wars: The Clone Wars” thus far. Minus Jar Jar getting far more screen time than he should (he should be replaced by someone else) and the general incompetency of Grievous it really is an amazing show thus far that manages to explore powerful themes related to war. These are two connected episodes that explore the theme of pacifism during war, the affects of war on neutral populations by larger powers and non-attachment.
The episodes directors were Rob Coleman and Steward Lee with the writers being Katie Lucas and Bill Canterbury.
The story involves Anakin suffering a major injury when he and Ahsoka rescue Aayla from her ship that the Separatists are destroying. They crash land on an unknown world and must look for a healer. They soon put the pacifist Lurmen in a difficult situation in aiding Anakin as the Separatists soon arrive to use their planet as a testing ground for a new weapon.
The Pros: The Lurmen – This species is designed to look like monkeys and they look sympathetic but not cute thankfully. We aren’t dealing with Ewoks here. They are also a complicated society with pacifism as a tradition that isn’t questioned until the Separatists want to use their village to test a new weapon. The leader’s son and the younger generation are the ones who fight though and embrace the new possibility of the Republic.
General Lok Durd – Voiced by the amazing George Takei, this guy is someone who has no concept of valuing life. For him everything is about power and position and he treats the Lurman like a slave casts raiding their village as an example of Separatist “Protection.” He has invented a weapon that destroys organic life but doesn’t get the chance to use it as Anakin destroys it and captures him. I hope we see this character again. He’s deadly and pompous and fun to see in action.
Aayla Secura – Secura teaches Ahsoka about the importance of non-attachment and tells about her own experience with it when her Master was gravely injured and the choice she had to make. She is a major part of the team and does a good job at walking the fine line in their dealings with the Lurman and fighting the Separatists.
Ahsoka – Ahsoka shows how much she is like Anakin in this when he almost dies when she asks to stay with him when if she had he might have been killed by the animals that were hunting. Because she goes with Aayla they find the Lurman village and it is her defense of them and conversation with them and inspires the Chieftain’s son to fight.
Anakin Skywalker – Anakin is out of commission for most of the episode and shows that he is capable of calm as he respects the Lurman’s pacifism and defends them from the Separatist weapon and army.
The Choices of the Neutral – In this episode we see the Chieftain of the Lurman always true tradition and pacifism and believes he is doing so to protect his people. We see later that a lot of it is just tradition and that he doesn’t want to lose his culture as their people will be wiped out by the weapon if they do not fight. His son and the younger generation choose to fight and in the end we see the Republic Fleet ominously arrive over the planet as he warns about what this might bring. His fears are validated in the end as the end result is the Empire. I wonder if the Lurman even exist anymore in the Imperial Era or if they were all wiped out.
Does Pacifism Work? – The question posed is the question of Pacifism working as a philosophy. I’d argue it can, but only if there aren’t any bullies or threats willing to take, kill or main you. If you do nothing you are letting greater evil occur and that is why Pacifism doesn’t work. By not fighting back the Chieftain was ready to let all his people die without even the chance for life. This shows that as an ideal it is great, but in practice against those who are ready to kill you, it is one of the worst paths that can be chosen.
On Attachment – Aayla tells Ahsoka that one person should not live so thousands can die. Echoing the Vulcan philosophy of the needs of the many outweighing the needs of the few. This is the reason for the Jedi Non-attachment as like Buddhist monks their goal is to live right action to the greatest degree and not be blinded by attachments when it may needlessly risk themselves or innocents.
These episodes were powerful, especially “Defenders of Peace,” which was better. They asked important questions and we saw people change. From Ahsoka becoming more Jedi than Anakin as she embraces non-attachment and in the Lurman choosing to fight after embracing pacifism for who knows how long. I’d highly recommend these two episodes. George Takei as Lok Durd was brilliant too. These stories show just how great this show can be and why at the end of these reviews, chances are it will have become a favorite show.
Final Score: 9.5 / 10.