This was an episode that was hard to watch due to how horrible the premise and characters were. Everyone and everything felt like a joke even though there were reasons it shouldn’t be. A strange threat on the Enterprise, the Klingons having a new weapon…a new species designed by the Klingons…all these are really cool but the story was just bad since it played it all for laughs rather than telling a good story.
The episode was directed by Hal Sutherland and written by David Gerrold.
The story involves the rescue of Cyrano Jones from the Klingons as they are attacking him for selling Tribbles on one of their planets. Things soon become dire when the Tribbles are growing uncontrollably and a new Klingon weapon paralyzes the Enterprise and their transportation of grain to Sherman’s Planet.
The Pros: Kirk – Kirk is shown to be a good captain in this. We see him negotiate with Koloth even though they are mortal enemies, and when push comes to shove is able to trick them into surrendering and providing them their Glommer (Tribble Killer) back. His annoyance of Cyrano Jones was what I also shared too.
The Cons: Cyrano Jones – This guy is annoying. He is clearly someone who wants to profit from any situation he is in, and he’s annoying as a Ferengi. There is nothing redeemable about this character and the only reason Kirk protects him is because he’s a Federation citizen. Guy ruined a Klingon world by selling them harmful pests (Tribbles).
The Tribbles – The Tribbles grow bigger and bigger and have none of the charm they do in the episodes they appear in. They aren’t shown to be creatures worth being a threat or a cute distraction. The episode had way too many references too. It should have tried better telling an original story.
Koloth and the Klingons – Koloth has a terrible voice actor and he spends the entire episode acting irrational. Couldn’t stand the character and he was nothing like his live action actor who played him as a general and someone worthy of being a threat and friend.
This was an episode I would not recommend. It doesn’t do comedy well at all as it can’t decide on what tone it wants and nothing is done with Cyrano Jones or the crew. All are watching Kirk make all the choices and being part of a big giant joke and reference to past “Original Series” episode. This is not a good episode at all.
Final Score: 3 / 10