“The Survivor” is a fun episode that doesn’t reach it’s full potential. We have a unique alien, Romulan intrigue and a character who most of the crew respects…within all of these ideas none of them are fully fleshed out. This is an episode that could have easily been a two-parter and deserved a full hour and the shortness of an animated show worked against the story hidden within.
The episode was directed by Hal Sutherland and written by James Schmerer.
The story involves the discovery of a man who was supposed to be dead named Carter Winston. All is not as it appears to be as the alien who has taken it’s form leads them into the Neutral Zone and into a dire confrontation with the Romulans. The crew must outsmart it and stop it before the Federation plans can get to the Romulans.
The Pros: The Romulans – The Romulans use an exiled shape-shifting Vendorian to get them the Enterprise and all the knowledge on the ship. They do a good job and almost succeed but in the end their worry about hurting the Vendorain keeps them from doing more damage to the Enterprise. This showed them as noble which I liked though their plan never felt fully fleshed out.
Captain Kirk and Spock – Kirk and Spock are great in this as the outsmart their opponent and force it to make a choice to defend the ship as well as calling the Romulans bluff which leads to the crew surviving and getting out of the Neutral Zone.
The Vendorian – The Vendorians have a great design! They look like a giant jellyfish and are pretty dangerous. I like the fact that they can shape-shift but wish they’d been fleshed out more. Still, this is a species I want to see again.
The Battle – The Battle is pretty great! 2 on 1 with Enterprise being sabotaged from within. The Romulans feel like a threat and nearly win and it is only from Kirk and Spock’s quick planning that force the Vendorian to make a choice and change sides.
Okay: Carter Winston and Anne Nored – This relationship doesn’t feel real and ends up being cliche. Nored sees past the alien whose form her husband took and she doesn’t shoot it and gets to stand guard over him at the end and the alien falls in love with her because of the form of it’s host. This would work better if it established the Vendorians took on more than just the appearance of another.
The Ending – The Vendorian decides that it will stand trial before the Federation because it is what Carter Winston would do and he was inspired by the man he took care of before he died. This would work a lot better if not for the question of why he was working for the Romulans? This makes it feel very incomplete.
This was a good episode but not great. As stated above there was so much more that could have been explored. Why was the Vendorian exiled from his Species and how did the Romulans get it to join them? How did being Carter Winston change him? Who was Carter Winston? What did the Romulans want in the end? These are all questions that remain unclear by episodes end, though the journey here is a lot of fun.
Final Score: 8 / 10