I really like “Supergirl,” after this season I still don’t feel comfortable calling it a great show, though if you are on the CW you probably aren’t a great show (experts of average or decent in their programming) but I am looking forward to next season and plan on coming back. In a nutshell, this was a season that needed a lot more focus and a lot less shipping as both these things held it back from being the great season it could have been.
The premise of this season involves Kara/Supergirl dealing with the threat of Cadmus (who wishes to destroy aliens on Earth) the Daxams and her new relationships with Lena Luthor (Lex’s sister) and Mon-El of Daxam.
The Pros: The Martian Arc – Martian Manhunter has an amazing arc where he hooks up with Miss Martian who is a White Martian who fights against her species who exterminated Martian Manhunter’s people. She takes their look and her arc is going back to find others to fight the fascist members of her people. She after returns with those allies in the finale to fight. The main arc for Manhunter is overcoming prejudice, and they handle that really well.
Superman – Superman is in the show this season and he is fantastic! He clashes with Martian Manhunter, he remembers to smile and is both charming and awkward and is used as an ally and threat to equal degree. I really liked Tyler Hoechlin’s portrayal of him and hope he is used again in this and other series.
James and the Guardian – After Kara breaks up with James at the beginning of the Season and Cat hands him Catco he realizes that being a superhero is what he missed in his life and he becomes the Guardian, a Batmanesque protector of the city. The arc isn’t done yet as Kara wants him to stop being this character, but he saves so many people and shows that a person can live in both worlds, even if they aren’t Kryptonian.
The Crossover Episodes – Supergirl is in 2 Crossover events, the first involves all the DC CW shows and the Dominator invasion, which is fantastic as Supergirl is a weapon at first and after has to pull back so she isn’t used against the team but still helps defeat the aliens and later in the episode where the Music Meister (a Q, God like being) helps The Flash and Supergirl face their relationship and heal the bonds with their partners. Both are a lot of fun and the second is a musical episode (in which all can sing well!) and were some of the best parts of this season.
The Daxamite Invasion – The finale is the Daxamite invasion as Mon-El rejects his parents and his mother in turn kills his father so that she can conquer Earth and get her son back. We see the Daxamites are warriors and Mon-El their prince rejected his culture. In the end he has to leave Earth as Supergirl, with Cadmus releases a small dose of lead into the atmosphere which can kill Daxamites, leading to their retreat and Supergirl’s good-bye to the man she came to love. The Fleet is still around as a potential threat though, even if they can’t attack Earth.
Okay: Cadmus – Cadmus has Kara and Alex’s father and he is used against them, Lena’s mother also run’s the organization. Early on Superman and the others are facing off against Metallo’s that were created by Cadmus to kill Kryptonians. Team Work defeats them and the organization is overall feckless. They attempt alien genocide a few times and fail. I like the idea of the organization but hate the execution.
The Cons: Lack of Focus – Cadmus, the Martian Arc, Winn’s alien relationship, James and the Guardian, the Crossover event, the Danvers and their father and the Daxamite you are given a cluttered season where none of these except the Bottle arcs really play out to their greatest potential.
Everybody Gets a Relationship aka Too Much Shipping – Alex hooks up, Kara hooks up, Winn hooks up and even Martian Manhunter hooks up…and so many arcs revolve around these dramas. This really took away from the story as these should have been happening in the background, not front in center…since making it front and center just made the show feel all about shipping characters.
The things that worked this season really worked. The Flash and Supergirl worked really well together and I loved seeing the CW Justice League, Martian Manhunter getting explored was wonderful (he is a favorite in most things I’ve seen this character in) and the finale was fantastic. If the show had only been these things it would be a great show, but too much shipping (everyone does not need to be hitched), Cadmus not really paying off and the lack of focus brought the show down to good. I would still recommend it for those who enjoyed Season 1 and I can’t wait for Season 3!
Final Score: 8 / 10