Avengers: Endgame (2019) – A Good but Deeply Flawed Film

New Avengers: Endgame Poster Reveals the New Team | Collider

        “Avengers: Endgame” is a good but really flawed movie. This is a film that had so many working parts, part of me is surprised it even worked at all. While another part of me really wishes it had focused on cleaning up the plot holes and story issues. Would I recommend this film? If you’ve come this far it is a nice way to finish on “The Avengers” story, even if it doesn’t all work. That is really the best review I can give you on it. It is at times really good but the holes it creates within it’s own lore are problems I think will be discussed long after Disney Plus and other “MCU” related content has sought to answer them.

The film was directed by Anthony and Joe Russo and written by Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeeley.

The story follows our heroes as they seek to live with what happened after Thanos’s snap at the end of “Infinity War.” They are left trying to deal until Ant-Man arrives, offering them a potential solution for bringing back all those they lost in the snap.

SPOILERS ahead

The Pros:

The Five Year Jump – I love that our heroes can’t just fix what happened easily. Right after the film we have the wait until Captain Marvel arrives, and than the survivors all go to Thanos in the Garden and kill him, but they can’t change what he did as he used the Infinity Stones to destroy the Infinity Stones. After that our heroes change, Thor goes into a dark depression, Black Widow becomes leader of the Avengers, Iron Man starts a family with Pepper Pots and they have a daughter, Bruce Banner become Professor Hulk, Captain America takes care of the survivors in their grief and Hawkeye becomes a vigilante named Rhonin. The others take care of their countries or are investigating strange occurrences around the universe. This time jump was smart in that showed that the events of “Infinity War” forever changed our characters, and for them there is no going back.

The Personal Moments – There are a lot of personal moments that stand out in “Endgame.” The moments largely come out of the time travel that is done when the Avengers are collecting the Infinity Stones scattered throughout time. We have Black Widow recruit Hawkeye in the lead-up and see how deep their friendship is, Tony talks to his dad Howard about being a Dad, Thor talks to his Mom who was killed in “Thor: The Dark Word,” and Thor and Rocket have a touching moment talking about loss and tragedy. These were the personal moments I loved in the film.

Scott Lang / Ant-Man – Ant-Man is the funniest part of the film and is also the emotional heart too as he is the one who realizes time travel might be the way for them to get the Infinity Stones and bring back those lost in the snap. He has some great jokes and his coming out of the Quantam Realm is powerful too as the world population has been halved so there has been a social breakdown since he’s been gone. When he discovers his daughter survived, it is one of the happiest moments in the film. You get why he’s willing to risk everything to bring back all those who were lost.

Bruce Banner / Hulk – Hulk after the five year jump is a character who has finally found balance and is easily the wisest out of all the Avengers. I wanted to know more about his life before the five year jump but the time we get with him helping with the plan is awesome. He has a sense of humor and because he has the Hulk body he needs help picking up smaller things. One of his big acts is to bring back those who were lost in the Snap, as he knows he is one of the few who can wield the Gauntlet without dying. I also like that this balanced Hulk came about because Hulk  and Bruce both lost to Thanos in “Infinity War.” Neither one could defeat him alone but together they were able to save everyone.

Thor – Thor is a broken character in this film. He’s lost his parents, his brother, his best friend and half his people to Thanos so after the five year jump he is a loner, gamer and drunk in New Asgard letting Valkyrie lead while he tries to escape from his failure. What helps him heal are his conversations with Rocket and when they visit the Asgard of the past to get the Aether (which is one of the “Infinity Stones” out of Jane Foster. Talking to his mother in past helps him deal with her lost that he’d experienced and Rocket helps him focus so that he later ready to fight Thanos once more. What all of this help him realize is that he isn’t fit to rule and has never done that. He’s always been the adventurer to joins the returned “Guardians of the Galaxy.”

Nebula – This is going to get a little confusing as there are 2 Nebulas in this film. The one I’m referring to is the one who was around after the five year jump and isn’t the one still serving Thanos that future Nebula kills (and isn’t canceled out somehow) in the film. This Nebula changes past Gamora and causes past Gamora to turn against Thanos in the final battle. Karen Gilllian truly owns this role and I can’t wait to see what they do with her in the future.

Tony Stark / Iron Man – This is really Tony’s story as after the five year jump he has a family and is raising a daughter with Pepper Pots and it is for them that he comes back to try and bring back all those lost during the snap. From here his arc is making peace with his eventual death as he does everything right, makes peace with Captain America and moves forward having all of them make a promise that they won’t erase what was built in the last five years. He’s the most responsible person in this entire story in regards to Time Travel, and he never loses sight of getting all the Infinity Stones to stop Thanos. His death is powerful too as he uses his snap to turn Thanos and his forces to dust as what was done to his friends before. This causes his death which is how the film is ended.

The Cons:

The Premise – Time travel plots are tough to do right and this one in refusing to lay down rules ends up leaving some very big plot holes with what it tries to do to bring everyone back and to have a character live out his life in the past. I really would have preferred a fight for the Infinity Stones against Thanos and that be the core plan but that is left early when Thanos gets killed off shortly after the snap but they learn he destroyed the Stones leaving Time Travel as really the only option. This was the first way they wrote themselves into a hole, and for me the problems are big enough that they gave me a lot of dislike for this film.

Lack of Thanos Kills -They find a way to bring back Thanos as with time travel past Thanos somehow learns about their plans from hacking future Nebula’s tech. This leads to him somehow pulling his forces to the present the Avengers are in. Well he shows up and he destroys the Avengers Compound. He reveals his full army and forces and says he’ll destroy Earth…and doesn’t kill a single person. For how dangerous he was in “Infinity War,” in this film he is just weak. I hated this. Tt took away from the sacrifices because based on how it was filmed it looked like the Avengers and their Allies would destroy him and his army anyway without anyone dying.

Time Travel Plot Holes – The best thing I can do here is just list them. The excuse I keep hearing is “Alternate Timelines” but what does that mean in regards to the state of the Universe and the fact that the Ancient One tells Hulk that removing the Infinity Stones from their proper place in time will lead to a worse timeline. Time for the plot holes.: Loki escapes with the Tesseract in the timeline of “The Avengers” movie now, Past Thanos was killed but that didn’t erase Future Thanos, Past Gamora is in the future which maybe erases Prime Gamora in the Soul Stone? or a different Soul Stone? Captain America delivers all the Infinity Stones back to where they belonged but stuck around to grow old as Agent Carter’s husband meaning at one point maybe 3 Captain Americas existed at once. As well as others. It is a mess and no emotional core can change how much this bothered me.

Captain America’s Ending – I’m coming back to this because this was the thing that annoyed me the most. At one point it looks as if they’ve set up Captain America’s death as the first death of Past Thanos. This would have been perfect as with the survivors returning his death could inspire everyone and no one else, or just Iron Man dying is more forgivable narratively. Instead he lives as an old man knowing that 2 Captain America’s were running around at one point and than proceeded to let Hydra rise again and countless other evils that happened over the course of the series that he couldn’t do because he was frozen in the ice. I hated this so much. In the end the writer’s gave us Captain America fanservice versus what the man we saw in the Marvel Cinematic Universe would do. This was a character who had duty and the protection of others above all else, and he got rid of it all to be selfish. The only thing I liked was Falcon becoming the new Captain America.

This is a film that I’d recommend to those who have come this far and want to see where the main Avengers end up. There are so many stories to tell in this Universe and I’m curious to see where they lead, though with the writing plot holes I also worry that we’ll see a decrease in quality come with it. An emotional core can only get a film so far. Your plot devices need to work properly and your characters have to make sense. In the end Captain America didn’t work for me and the Time Travel plot kept it from being great. I would have rather had the five year jump and them fight Thanos in the present and force Prime Thanos to rethink his original agenda after they get a hold of an Infinity Stone so Thanos can’t just snap again to fix things. Prime Thanos was compelling and Past Thanos is just nothing. He has a lot of faceless minions and ends up being more of an Ultron, which he wasn’t in “Infinity War.” So, check this film out if you have come this far. I really worry what will come out of the MCU after this. I worry this film may have created more problems than it solved.

Final Score: 8 / 10 Initially it was a higher score but the problems have bothered me more than the things I like, the longer I’ve thought about the film. It is solidly good, but the flaws keep it from greatness.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s