“Absolute Candor” is my favorite episode of “Star Trek: Picard” so far. There is a complete story, a great exploration of Romulan lore and it focuses in on the core relationships that make up the plot. Outside of the pilot episode of the series this is the most focused story so far. I’m glad that even though this is a long form story that within that there can still be solid individual character stories to strengthen it overall.
The episode was directed by Jonathan Frakes and written by Michael Chabon.
Picard takes the ship to Vashti, a planet of Romulan Refugees seeking help in his quest against the Tal Shiar.
The Cost of the Supernova – Vashti is a planet of Romulan Refugees that has quite a few different groups of Romulans we meet. We meet xenophobic ones who hate outsiders because of how they were left behind and also the religious side of the Romulans in the Qowat Milat, a religious order of warrior nuns. This exploration of people and culture is one of the things I love most about “Star Trek” and this episode is a shining example of doing it well.
The Qowat Milat – Picard is friends with the Qowat Milat leaders on Vashti as he was working with them to resettle the refugees before his resignation. They are really cool and I liked their leader Zani. The belief of the order is to speak truthfully and clearly in all emotions and thoughts. They are enemies of the Tal Shiar and part of their beliefs involve taking up a cause they believe to be a lost cause. Elnor, a boy so he cannot be one of them carries their philosophy and it is his story that drives this story besides Picard.
Elnor – Elnor is an orphan raised by the Qowat Milat. He had curiosity about the outside world but anger at Picard for leaving them. What leads to him changing his mind is seeing Picard in danger and realizing Picard does need him. He ends up killing a Romulan Senator who was dueling Picard after he the senator ignores his warning. I’m curious to see how he’s developed further as he seems to have forgiven Picard and since he was a kid he wanted to see what was beyond Vashti. The vibe I get from is Odo or Data as he gives us the outsider perspective on a crew full of humans.
Picard – Picard comes to Vashti as he is driven by his guilt and he does need help from the Qowat Milat in his quest against the Tal Shiar. The episode is him atoning to Qowat Milat, Elnor and the people of the planet for Starfleet leaving them behind. It is powerfully done and it is hear we see the humanitarian Picard is as he berates Elnor for killing the senator, as he believed it did not have to happen. I loved seeing this Picard again as so often in the films he was first to violence, not alternatives.
The Mystery of Soji – Soji’s story is still the weakest part of the narrative as it is still one giant mystery. In this episode we learn about Romulan myths about a Destroyer and one of the former Romulan drones believes Soji is that Destroyer from Romulan mythology. Her reaction causes the other former Romulan drones to react the same way. This could go many ways and is still incomplete, which is why I have as okay. It could be a pro or con depending on how it plays out in the end.
It is great seeing Jonathan Frakes in the director’s chair again. He’s directed countless “Star Trek” episodes from many series and in this he took the time for us to get to know Elnor and the Romulans on Vashti. I look forward to seeing him appear as Riker as he is an awesome person and actor and the fact that he’s directing means he must have seen this project as worth taking on. I hope we get more episodes like this as it is in getting to know characters and the world where “Trek” really soars.
Final Score: 8.7 / 10 The Soji story is the weakest part and what keeps it from being rated higher.