Star Trek: The Original Series – Season 3, Episode 10 – “For the World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky” – McCoy and the Quest for Truth

     “For the World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky” is a a great classic “TOS” episode and also works well as just a great science fiction conflict. I was looking for an episode that explores Dr. McCoy and this one does so really well. This is an episode with multiple stakes that are juggled really well as we see both mortality on the individual and large scale level.

The episode was directed by Tony Leader and written by Rik Vollaerts.

The episode involves the crew of the Enterprise when they discover a generational ship on a crash course with an inhabited planet and must stop it. Dr. McCoy also learns he’s carrying a terminal illness and only has a year to live.

SPOILERS ahead

The Pros:

The Premise – The generational ship full of people who have never known anything but the ship who may unknowingly destroy another civilization and McCoy facing his own mortality leads to great drama being created. We have the interpersonal relationship with the crew and how the crew interacts with the Fabrini people leading to an amazing story.

The Oracle – The Oracle is a great antagonist. It is driven by it’s programming and is able to defend itself extremely well. It is so driven by it’s programming that it is unable to accept any mistakes or the fact that it had made a mistake. The final fight against it is intense too as it tries to burn Spock, Kirk and McCoy in the room before they can use the book to shut it down. The Oracle has the upper hand through most of the episode which made it’s defeat all the more rewarding.

Captain Kirk and Spock – Kirk and Spock are the ones who help Natira realize the Oracle is wrong and they are the first to investigate the Oracle. We also get some good emotional moments where we see empathy in both of their eyes when Kirk mentions McCoy’s illness. It was a subtle moment but it made me appreciate Spock more who clearly showed carrying for Bones in the way he looked at him after hearing about the illness. This is an episode where the trio does a great job saving the day and in the end they discover on the computer’s harddrive a way to save McCoy as as well.

Natira – Natira is the leader of the Fabrini in that she is the one who speaks listens to the Oracle and enforces it’s will. Even with this indoctrination she received growing up she is willing to accept she is in a ship eventually and that there outside that the Oracle is hiding from her. She takes this responsibility deeply to the point that though she loves Dr. McCoy she does not return with him to the Enterprise.

Dr. McCoy – Dr. McCoy carries the episode as we seem him wrestle with the fact that he is dying and that when he chooses to stay on the ship to live out his last days he acts to help the Enterprise, even as he nearly loses his life in the process. We have moments of him facing his mortality with the other members of the crew and he clearly loved Natira. It is for these reasons it is really his episode as they would not have succeeded in stopping the ship without his sacrifice when he stayed behind and risked the Oracles wrath. In the end by saving the people on the planet and the truth saving the Fabrini people also leads to them finding the cure for McCoy and saving him as well.

This episode gives us an interesting people, uses our main three (Kirk, Spock and McCoy) in dramatic ways and provides a great antagonist in the Oracle and fantastic supporting character in Natira. The fact that this is a ship that can sustain itself and the Fabrini culture that has arisen from it fascinating too. Suffice to say, this is an episode I highly recommend.

Final Score: 10 / 10

Star Trek: The Original Series – Season 1, Episode 23 – “A Taste of Armageddon” – The Possibility of Peace

     “A Taste of Armageddon” is one of my favorite episodes of “The Original Series.” This is an episode that explores what it means to tackle the costs of war as well as how a society could buy into constant war for a state of false “peace.” This episode also uses most of the main crew and works fantastically as an ensemble piece. Suffice to say, this is one I highly recommend.

The episode was directed by Joseph Pevney with teleplay by Robert Hamner (who also wrote the story) and Gene L. Coon.

The story involves the Enterprise delivering Ambassador Robert Fox to open up negotiations with the Eminian Union who have been war with another planet in their system Vendikar for generations. All is not as it appears to be though when Kirk and the away team beam down during an attack from Vendikar.

SPOILERS ahead

The Pros:

The War – The war with Vendikar is the core part of the episode as it has gone on so long that the way of fighting has been completely taken over by computers and citizens on both sides now sacrifice themselves in areas where the computer says attacks occurred. This is taken as normal because it is all the 2 planets have known and it is the arrival of the Enterprise where the cycle of war is finally broken by bringing back an actual war not the virtual war where people willingly go to their deaths for the “Good of the state.” The war has warped all sense of valueing people as Anan 7 tries multiple times to trick Enterprise in lowering the shields so it can be destroyed as in the virtual war, it was.  Though even in this, when the war stops the desire for peace is still strong among those who have been a part of this war for so long.

Mea 3 and Anan 7 – Mea 3 and Anan 7 give us a great glimpse of the mentality that has been built up by war. Anan 7 is doing all he can to kill the Enterprise because he fears the war escalating when the virtual deaths aren’t registered while Mea 3 is a true believer but does nothing to stop Kirk and Spock from breaking all the death machines. In the end they are both flawed and human as in the end Anan 7 does accept Ambassador Fox’s help at negotiating a peace with Vendikar as he doesn’t want a war where he’ll see the bombs dropping and bloodshed. He could fight a sterilized war because that had been the way of things for so long and was willing to talk to make the change needed for the possibility of peace.

Scotty -Scotty is Captain while Kirk and Spock lead the away team on the planet. He does a fantastic job and keeps the ship safe as he figures out that Anan 7 is lying when he calls for them all to come down for shore leave and keeps the shields up even against orders of the Ambassador. This is an amazing Scotty episode and made me wish we saw him in the Captain’s chair more. He is more than qualified for it and will fight for his crew. He also plays of McCoy really well who is extremely anxious through the entire episode.

Spock – Spock calls out the Eminian Union in a great way where he see’s the logic in how they do war but does not see it as moral. We also see how powerful he is psychically when he controls the guards to free them and helps lead the revolution on the planet to stop the machines of death. He plays off Kirk really well too as it is them planning together when they are trapped to get out of each situation.

Captain Kirk – This is a great Captain Kirk episode. We get a Kirk speech that war has to be experienced to truly know how awful it is as he advocates for life and humanity. It is a fantastic Kirk speech and seeing him playoff Spock throughout the episode is handled really well.

The Cons:

Vendikar – We never see the people of Vendikar and that is really the only con I can think of. They are only mentioned when seeing them, even at the end would have shown their humanity as well. I’m honestly surprised the episode never showed us even one.

This is an amazing episode and easily one of the best of “The Original Series.” “The Original Series” was strongest when it worked the ensemble cast and explored deeper ideals tied to one’s humanity or the nature of war and peace. There is so much about this episode that works and it captures so much of what I loved about “The Original Series.”

Final Score: 9.6 / 10

Star Trek: The Original Series – Season 2, Episode 7 – “Wolf in the Fold” – Scotty on Trial

Star Trek S02E07 Wolf in the Fold - video dailymotion

   “Wolf in the Fold” provides an interesting premise and even has some good moments of tension before it fails as a story. This is an episode that focuses on Scotty, but we learn almost nothing about him, and even the main threat ends up not feeling like a threat. This is all besides the misogyny that runs through the episode. The premise had a lot of promise but absolutely fails and I’ll get into why below.

The episode was directed by Joseph Pevney and written by Robert Bloch.

The story involves Scotty being blamed for a murder when the crew visits Argelius II.

SPOILERS ahead

The Pros:

The Politics – In this story we see the politics between Argelius and Starfleet. Argelius is a free love society that hasn’t experienced a murder until the one that kicks off the episode. This gives an interesting dynamic as Kirk wants to do it by their laws but ends up offering up the computer as an answer when the Prefect is willing to try it after his wife is murdered during a seance to find the truth. From this, I wish he’d pushed back against more. He is the final judge on Scotty’s fate but he is very agreeable with Starfleet, even after his wife is murdered.

The Computer – The idea of using the computer to find the truth is really neat. It has all the information and can track if a person is lying or not. It is from the computer they found out the spirit of Jack the Ripper is the one responsible. This part of the episode is slow but I liked the computer being used the solve the mystery. It fit the theme of tech. solutions over supernatural which has always been a theme of “Star Trek.”

The Premise – The idea of a member of the crew being framed for murder on an alien world is fascinating. This base premise alone would have been enough if the politics between Argelius II and the Federation had been played up. Sadly the idea of the premise is not paid off.

The Cons:

Misogyny – Everyone woman we meet in this story is either being ogled by the crew (the belly dancer who gets killed) or is responsible for a problem. Scotty is on shoreleave because a female crewman caused a problem that lead to him hitting his head. This is so weak and isn’t helped by the text of the episode as all the other woman who we meet end up needing rescuing from Jack the Ripper or are killed by him.

The Enemy – Jack the Ripper is the enemy and his main host ends up being Mr. Hengist, an Argelian who is played by John Fiedler who voices Piglet in “Winnie the Pooh.” This does not work. Piglet’s voice is not ever threatening and the spirit taking control of the ship is for such a short time we don’t even see what the enemy is capable of. The moment the killings end on Argelius II all tension is gone and that is largely through how Jack the Ripper is presented. He just isn’t scary.

The Ending – The crew ends up fighting Jack the Ripper and him existing through fear by being pumped full of drugs that induce happiness by McCoy. This causes such whiplash that I don’t know why it was even included in the episode and focused on. Everyone is laughing, which takes away what tension there was by Jack the Ripper taking control of the ship.

This was an episode full of interesting ideas that it can’t execute. No ideas are delved into deeper and the supernatural threat just isn’t threatening. I appreciate that the episode is about someone outside of Kirk, McCoy or Spock but Scotty just doesn’t get enough exploration. This episode is reactive when it could have been so much more. There are the seeds of good ideas here, but failure to explore any of those ideas deeply leads to a bad episode.

Final Score: 5 / 10

Star Trek: The Original Series – Season 1, Episode 4 – “The Enemy Within” – The Jekyll and Hyde of Kirk

Watch Star Trek: The Original Series (Remastered) Season 1 Episode ...

    “The Enemy Within” is a good thriller episode of “The Original Series.” This series explores identity in a fascinating way and gives us a good ticking clock for the tension. The episode also has some major problematic elements that I’ll be getting into below. I’m going to give a trigger warning as well for what happens in the episode.

The episode was directed by Leo Penn and written by Richard Matheson.

The story follows the problem of a transporter malfunction that separates Kirk into a good and evil version, neither who can live without the other. The crew must stop his doppelganger and save Sulu and the archaeologists trapped on the planet below.

SPOILERS ahead

The Pros:

The Premise – The premise of a Captain forced to deal with both sides of himself and have the ticking clock of saving his crew is such a great premise for creating tension. The stakes are immediately apparent and gives a chance to explore human nature and identity.

Scotty – Scotty is engineer and transporter chief and spends most of the episode trying to solve the problem of the separated Kirk. In the end he does find a technical solution and they are able to make Kirk whole again and rescue the crew.

Sulu and the Trapped Crew – Sulu is on the planet and we see him holding onto hope as the situation on the planet continues to get worse as the temperature drops. I loved how he was still able to joke and was looking out for those around him. We got to see him problem solve as well as at one point he warms a rock with his phaser which helps give himself and the archaeologists more time.

Exploration of Identity – The exploration of identity is key to the episode. Kirk has to take his selfish side as it helps him make decisions and be decisive. Without it he is passive and in flight mode versus his evil which is permanent fight mode. It takes time for him to accept that side of himself though and it is only through Spock expressing how his intelligence is what helps him make peace between the Vulcan and Human sides of himself. The dynamic between Kirk and Spock works really well in the episode.

The Cons:

Shatner Ham – Shatner’s evil side doesn’t have any subtly until moments at the end where he is much more cool headed. I get Shatner was going for pure Hyde animal but it was over the top on more than one occasion. This is definitely a Shatner ham episode and it overall doesn’t work. Because he is so over the top his doppelganger never fully comes off as a fully realized threat as Kirk is not superhuman, his other half is just animal crazy and not a smart animal.

Rape Apologism and Yeoman Rand – We have Spock at the end saying how the Doppelganger had “interesting” aspects to Yeoman Rand, who the doppelganger tried to rape and we have Rand makes excuses for the Captain after she was violated. I hated this so much. Within the progressive future of Gene Roddenberry you still had this crap from the era of the woman being blamed for what was done to her. The whole scene has more worry for Kirk than Rand when she comes forward. God I hated it so much.

If this episode wasn’t trying to apologize for the doppleganger’s attempt to rape Yeoman Rand than I would be rating this episode higher. We get some amazing exploration of Kirk’s identity and a good ticking clock problem to be solved. I would recommend this episode but with a warning about how Rand is handled in the episode. She should have never had to apologize for what was done to her and I hated how even Spock seemed to make light of it in the final scenes when Kirk is whole again. She deserved so much better than her treatment in this story.

Final Score: 8 / 10 Elevated for how it explores identity. Could have been great if Rand had been respected as a person and character.

Star Trek Continues – A Beautiful Continuation and Honoring of the Best Parts of the Original Series

This is the first fan series or project that I’ve reviewed on the blog, and honestly after this, the standards for what fan films or shows I would watch is pretty high. A friend at work recommended it to me and I’m grateful he did. This is a professionally made production that looks just as good if not a little better than the Star Trek: The Original Series and has writing on par with the good and great episodes from that series.

The show was created by Vic Mignogna, who also stars as Captain Kirk in the series…and you can tell he’s a fan of the series. So much love and quality was poured into the making of this that I honestly wish CBS would show it. This is more than just a love letter to the series as it takes the lore seriously and expands on it, rather than going through the same beats.

The story picks up where the Original Series left off with the continuation of the 5 year mission of the Enterprise.  As part of that mission they are first to try out the Counselor test program (on whether starships should bring on full time counselors) bringing lieutenant Dr. McKennah to the crew.

The Pros: The Universe – This is “Star Trek.” The characters act how they do in the Original Series, the ships and galactic powers are in action, the Enterprise is exploring strange new worlds. Nothing feels out of place.

The Cinematography – The cinematography in this series is beautiful and it looks like a more polished version of how the Original Series was filmed of old. Whether it is fighting a Romulan Warbird or destroying a tiny object in space, or a fight on the ship or a planet…the sets look raw and real and it gives life to the show.

The Writing – The writing team and directors (who were largely Vic Micnogna working with a few other people but usually always at least directing) did an amazing job. The stories catch the morality of what make “Star Trek” great, whether it is feminism, equality and peace and understanding aliens and other beings. This is the through line through the series and it was one thing the Original Series didn’t always do (seriously, the sexism in some of the early episodes of TOS are horrifyingly bad). I won’t give away any spoilers but these episodes are so amazing I do plan individual reviews of them down the line, as well as a Top 3 post.

Connecting to Past and Future Treks – This is a series that connects the threads between TOS and The Motion Picture really well (and even ties into TNG with the Counselor program). In this you see what happens to the psychics, the Romulan Star Empire after the Klingon Alliance, Apollo, why we never seen any female captains and how things went down in the Mirror Universe. It is all done artfully while keeping the progressive strength of what made Star Trek so great in how it saw humanity’s potential in the future.

The Guest Stars – There are some pretty great guest stars, even though some of them I wish had gotten better writing. Colin Baker shows up as an alien leader, as does John De Lancie, Rekha Sharma shows up a scientist who Kirk had a relationship with, Marina Sirtis voices the Enterprise computer and Michael Dorn voices the Mirror Universe’s Enterprise computer. The guest stars in this are gold and they do a good job with what the writers give them.

Spock and Kirk – Spock and Kirk are the strongest part of this show and that is largely due to the chemistry between Vic Mignogna and Todd Haberkorn. Both have done anime voice work so my guess is that is how they must have met and formed the rapport. These are the two who receive the most exploration as we see both of their regrets as well as their dreams and aspirations. I won’t say anymore than that as the reveals of what those things are handled really well. Even when certain episodes were just good or fun these two kept me coming back as their acting was the strongest even in weak scenes.

Okay: The Rest of the Crew – Chris Doohan (James Doohan’s son) is fine, hell most of the crew outside of Kirk and Spock who aren’t guest stars are fine but none of them really capture the characters the way Kirk and Spock do. Part of the reason is they changed the McCoy actor after two episodes and Chekov, Uhura and Sulu really don’t get any more exploration than what they did in the Original Series, so that was a wasted opportunity and kept them from ever being good.

This is a series I highly recommend to any fan of “Star Trek.” This is a series that develops the characters further, introduces new threats and situations that have to be solved, is full of hope and inspiration for the future and beautifully captures all the good that has come out of “Star Trek.” Here is the website:

http://www.startrekcontinues.com/index.html

I highly recommend you check it out if you are a fan of the series. Seriously, Vic Mignogna created something wonderful that I will be coming back to again and again.

Final Score: 9 / 10 Solidly great fan series that connects TOS to The Motion Picture.

Star Trek Beyond (2016): The Reboot Series Finally Captures Classic “Star Trek”

Star Trek Beyond

    “Star Trek Beyond,” is a film that best captures the spirit of the Star Trek Franchise than probably “The Undiscovered Country.” That film has a better story and is one of my all time favorite Star Trek Films but this film is still really good and I enjoyed it a lot more than “Star Trek Into Darkness,” which at the end of the day depended way too much on conspiracy and fan service rather than showing the spirit and cost of adventure the way this film does. Non-spoiler thoughts…this film has great action, comedy and characters and is well worth your time to see it on the big screen.

    “Star Trek Beyond” was directed by Justin Lin, written by Simon Pegg and Doug Jung and produced by J.J. Abrams, Roberto Orci and Bryan Burk.

     The story takes place 3 years into the 5 year mission and Kirk (Chris Pine) finds himself at a crossroads with the possibility of promotion and Spock (Zachary Quinto) is pulled back into Vulcan after a major death.  They and the crew are put to the test though when they are lead into a trap and must face Krall (Idris Elba) who destroys their ship, forcing them to adapt to the planet and keep him from getting the superweapon he seeks.

SPOILERS ahead

The Pros: The World – This movie captures the wonder of the World of Star Trek. We get the Utopia of Yorktown, the horrors of war via Krall and tons of alien species and first contact opportunities.

Yorktown – Yorktown is a like a giant snowglobe in space and looks like how I always imagined a advanced space station actually looking (in the tv shows they never were able to capture it like it is on film, they are just stations, this is a city). I loved this area and I like that we spent time here to humanize our crew and see how the Federation has achieved Utopia.

The Writing – Minus the writing of Krall, the writing is a major pro. Every character is given things to do, characters change and aren’t just rehashing the same story (Kirk, Spock and Uhura had the same story twice in the last two reboot films). Simon Pegg being a Trekkie and one of the writers is one reason I think why this worked so much.

Cinematography – The cinematography is beautiful and stunning and captures the old look of the show while modernizing it for the screen. It feels dreamlike and from it the adventure of this great series.

The Comedy – The comedy is gold, especially anything with Jaylah and Scotty and McCoy and Spock. The dialogue is quick and witty and always moves the action forward.

Use of Ensemble Cast – The cast all has things to do and it keeps the story strong! Uhura and Sulu are protecting the hostages and the device, Chekov is with Kirk, McCoy is Spock and Scotty is with Jaylah. Each of them are working to find one another and defeat Krall and it leads to great comedic and dramatic moments.

The Cast – The cast is the strongest part of this film, these actors have come to inhabit these characters.

Chekov – R. I. P. Anton Yelchin…you really inhabited this role. This is a film where Chekov is with Kirk for a lot of it and later teams up with Scotty since he knows tech. almost as well. We see him be the hero and the problem solver and his relationship with Kirk is pretty great. You’ll be missed Anton…

Sulu – John Cho is fantastic as Sulu and in this we get to meet his husband and daughter at Yorktown and from there see the reason why he is fighting so hard to defend it. In this he get to see him fly the Franklin, fight with the Enterprise until Krall’s drones destroy it. It is great seeing him and Uhura team up.

Uhura – Uhura is the primary protector of the hostages and the device that Krall is trying to get. She only loses when Krall threatens a crew member forcing the crewman to reveal her hand and where she’s kid the device. Uhura is ready to die to protect it though. We also see that her and Spock still have a great relationship even though they may or may not have broken up. Zoe Saldana is fantastic.

Scotty – Simon Pegg is really great in the role of Scotty and in this we see him as the major problem solver, whether it is fixing the Franklin, finding the crew and Krall or working with Jaylah on traps.

McCoy – Karl Urban really owns the role of McCoy and in this we get to see his friendship with Spock grow as they are stuck together for most of the film. It is great seeing their dynamic as McCoy’s cynical optimism is contrasted beautifully with Spock’s cold clear logic and duty driven decisions. This eventually leads to them taking on Krall by kidnapping one of the drone ships since Spock needs someone to monitor his injury he received when the Enterprise was destroyed and McCoy is the only one who knows about it.

Spock – Spock is faced with a decision in this…to stay with the crew or to return to Vulcan to help create more Vulcans. Ambassador Spock has died and no Vulcan is once more lacking limited leaders and there still aren’t very many of them. Over the course of the film he decides to stay for the crew though, not because of future Spock and I really like that. He discovers that it is out on the frontier he can protect Vulcan best and the realization that the entire crew is his family now and will be (he sees a picture of the crew when they are older that Ambassador Spock was keeping).

Kirk – Kirk like Spock is faced with a decision to stay or get a promotion and go as when we first meet him his life on the ship has become mundane and he expresses how trapped everyone feels out in space for so long. It is powerful as he is really talking about himself. Krall reminds him of why he is out there too and even though he loses the Enterprise he decides to stay to Captain and because the Captain of the newly built Enterprise-A we see being built at the end of the film.

Jaylah -Sofia Boutella is awesome as Jaylah and I hope she becomes part of the main crew. She is the one who helps them all team up as her home is Krall’s old Federation ship the Franklin. It is thanks to her and Scotty that they get it running and are able to use it as a base to free the hostages and to confront Krall and his drone forces. She also has a somewhat romantic thing with Scotty and is an orphan whose been fighting Krall all her life. Suffice to say she is awesome.

The Idea of Krall – The idea of Krall as a former Space Marine turned alien warlord is cool. Peace doesn’t work for everyone, especially those who gain honor from combat and live from it (one reason the Federation fights the Klingons every generation even after the treaties). There was so much more that could have been done with this idea if he had just been fleshed out more as a character.

Remembering the Dead – R.I.P. Leonard Nimoy and Anton Yelchin. Both of them were given time to be remembered as Spock remembered Ambassador Spock and the final scene was fade to black with “For Anton” in memory of Anton Yelchin. The two of them were amazing and have left a legacy on this universe and the world.

Okay: Krall/Balthazar Edison – Idris Elba is good at humanizing this ex-marine turned alien Warlord and his acting is great, it is just the writing for Krall is only so-so so I’m putting him at okay. We never get explanations of why he turned into an alien or how using people turned him back into a person.

The Cons: Villain plan – The villain plan is to destroy Yorktown, which if Krall want the Federation at war, that isn’t going to help…since there is no way could escape, it was do the most damage and die…which I expected more from a man who had lived hundreds of years. He should have had a better plan.

How did Balthazar become Krall and Revert Back? – Balthazar was a M.A.C.O. (Pre-Federation Marine) who is maid captain after the Xindi and Romulan wars and finds himself abandoned on the planet. Something happens that causes him to become the alien Krall and he is using people to turn back into a person. This is never explained.

Pacing – The pacing can be a bit jarring at times. Sometimes everything is going too fast and we have no time to really soak in what our characters are going through, and other times we linger too long. This is most true at the beginning but by about a third of the way through the film this isn’t as much of an issue.

   The villain isn’t bad but he is where most of the holes in the plot are. Sometimes the pacing can be a little jarring, and I was bored at one point because of it…but the payoff when they arrive on Krall’s world is fantastic and almost everything after that works. This is a film that reminded me why I’m a Trekkie and I can’t wait to go back and review the other films so I can rate them all against one another. This a film well deserving of it’s place in the Franchise and some of the most fun I’ve had at the movies this summer.

Final Score: 8.5 / 10

Star Trek: The Animated Series – Season 1, Episode 11 – “The Terratin Incident” – Adapting to Size

Star Trek TAS Season 1 ep 11

      “The Terratin Incident” was an episode that could have easily been terrible. Shrinking people is generally a weak story unless something creative is done with it. This episode actually deals with consequences along those lines, and gives us a faction that isn’t all that sympathetic giving our heroes more of a dilemma.

    The episode was directed by Hal Sutherland and written by Paul Schneider.

     The story involves the crew being shrunk after investigating a planet full of dilithium and volcanic activity. The crew must find out who did it and restore themselves to normal size before they are destroyed.

The Pros: Captain Kirk – Kirk saves the day and figures out going down to the planet will be the way to figure out how to restore them to normal size. He also makes a splint for Sulu when Sulu is knocked off his post and he rescues Nurse Chapel. This is very much a Kirk episode. He is also merciful and saves the people who were attacking them.

Spock – Spock is the planner and Kirk is the doer. He figures out that they are shrinking first and works with Kirk to try and figure out a way to get them back to full size again.

Sulu – Sulu wants to attack the planet and is one of the first people who notices that something needs to be done about the planets attack on them.

Scotty – Scotty uses his men to use the transporter and is always active and creative throughout the episode. He doesn’t let size stop him from being productive and planning.

The Terratins – The Terratins were shrunk when they settled on the world and were lost to time. They chose not to seek help until the very end and steal others to get help. They are a great antagonist force in the episode.

The Cons: How Women are Handled – The women on the ship panic, especially when their jewelry shrinks and Nurse Chapel has to be rescued from drowning. This brought the episode way down and kept it from being better.

   Minus how women are handled in the episode it is a lot of fun and great. We get to see the crew think creatively, there are stakes and the Terratins though they were once human are now more alien as they do not know how to admit they are wrong and are so driven by pride and having to be right. It’s really cool and creates a great episode.

Final Score: 9 / 10

Star Trek: The Animated Series – Season 1, Episode 10 – “Mudd’s Passion” – Mudd is a Terrible Person and this Episode is Weak

Harcourt_Fenton_Mudd_2269

    Harry Mudd is a terrible character and I’m not looking forward to my eventual watching of “Mudd’s Women” his introduction episode. In this he is a simple and very selfish con who has no redeeming qualities. This episode also suffers from “Star Trek” not being all that good at comedy. Still, there were a few things I enjoyed, though this is still not an episode I’d recommend.

“Mudd’s Passion” was directed by Hal Sutherland written by Stephen Kandel.

The story involves Mudd conning some minors with love crystals that end up working and leading the crew to act crazy as he makes his escape and must be captured once again to be brought to justice within the Federation.

The Pros: Spock and Kirk – The crystals make these two lovy with one another and I love it as I have always been a fan of Spock and Kirk as more than friends but also potential lovers, as they had more chemistry with one another than any woman that was supposed to be a love interest.

The Rock Monsters – At one point Rock Monsters are attacking Mudd and Nurse Chapel and they have a great design.

The Cons: The Premise – They to go to stop a con job by Harry Mudd on a world that isn’t even under the Federation, it is pointless from the beginning and Nurse Chapel falling for the con against a proven con is just bad writing.

The Message – Love can be induced by artificial means? I don’t think this episode knew what it was exploring and any message gleaned is a negative.

The Characters – With the exception of Kirk and Spock everyone is written terribly. So much flirting and acting stupid for contrived reasons. Not worth your time.

Harry Mudd – Why did they bring this guy back? He is useless, annoying and if he is anything like this in his introduction episode I am going to run into an episode that I will probably hate. Of all the people to bring back…why not Kor or one of the Klingons or the Romulan Empress? Not Harry “fracking” Mudd.

Mudd and terrible writing are the biggest problems with this episode. It reminds me why in improv my mentor Brian told was that acting drunk was a copout, this was that with contrived writing. It was trying to be easy rather than telling a good story. I do not recommend at all and and Harry Mudd is a terrible character.

Final Score: 2 / 10

Star Trek: The Animated Series – Season 1, Episode 7 – “The Infinite Vulcan” – New Purpose

Spock_2,_Keniclius_5,_and_Enterprise_crew

  Walter Koenig (the actor who plays Chekov) is a great writer! He has a lot of big ideas he deals with in this (the survival of a dying species and how to change ideals) and does a really good job with it! This was an episode that could have been terrible. Clones generally are a bad idea, especially cloning a major character, but this episode rises above this generally bad idea.

   “The Infinite Vulcan” was directed by Hal Sutherland and written by as stated above, Walter Koenig.

      The story involves the Enterprise being ordered to a planet at the far reaches of the galaxy where a dying plant species called the Phylosians has made a deal with a man from the Eugenic Wars who has chosen Spock to clone in order to create his Master Race to bring peace to the galaxy. It is up to the crew to stop him.

The Pros: Phylos – Phylos is a really cool planet. It is entirely made of plant life with both predatory flying plants as enemies and the dying race of the Phylos as the dominant species. It is colorful, green and dangerous and I wish the planet would make appearance in other “Trek” things.

The Phylosians – This species is fascinating as they latch onto the man Dr. Stavos who almost killed them from his germs but did everything to save him. They were once a war making species but now only want to be peacekeepers…much like humanity and Dr. Stavos.

Uhura – Uhura has a minor but great role in this. She researches the Eugenic Wars and finds that Stavos fought in it and it is from her research they are able to reason with the man and Spock 2 in order to save Spock and keep Stavos’s ideals from becoming a nightmare. 

Sulu – Sulu also has an active role in this as it is the Phylosians who save him from a plant that poisons him and it is he who later defends them when they are attacked by the Phylosians by easily throwing one. He shows that he is adapt, witty and can match wits with any crewmember or alien. He’s a lot of fun in this and Takei brings his charm.

Scotty – Is the acting Captain and does a good job as we see that he is the one who tries everything to reach Kirk as he doesn’t want to cause a war during first contact. He truly is the best engineer in “Star Trek.”

Dr. Stavos – Stavos is the idealist run amok who has lost all faith in humanity so wants to create a master race to enforce peace between worlds. He ran away from the Eugenic Wars because of the ashamed he was of his people and the war and that shame rubbed off on him when he nearly wiped out the Phylosians from simply being part human. This makes it possible to reason with him though and in the end he becomes an ally of the Federation.

Spock and Spock 2 – Spock 2 is Spock’s Clone who has Stavos’s ideals but also the Vulcan logic which leads to him stopping further clones from being created and mind melding with the original Spock in order to save him. He later stays to help Stavos further his research and save the Phylosians.

Spock agrees with the Clone and calls out Kirk for his aggression while complimenting him for when he acts with a cool head.

Kirk –  This is a good Kirk episode as we see him deal with threats in a reasoned way while still using force when absolutely necessary. He is convincing too and manages to turn the Phylosians and Dr. Stavos who were once enemies into allies of the Federation.

    This was a really great episode with the only cons being the fact that what Dr. Stavos did during the Eugenic Wars is never gone into. In a way it isn’t needed but it would have made the episode perfect if we had more time. I really recommend this episode. I had no idea Walter Koenig could write, but he did a great job.

Final Score: 9.5 / 10

Star Trek: The Animated Series – Season 1, Episode 6 – “The Survivor” – Choice of the Outcast

Star Trek The Animated Series Season 1 Ep 6

  “The Survivor” is a fun episode that doesn’t reach it’s full potential. We have a unique alien, Romulan intrigue  and a character who most of the crew respects…within all of these ideas none of them are fully fleshed out. This is an episode that could have easily been a two-parter and deserved a full hour and the shortness of an animated show worked against the story hidden within.

    The episode was directed by Hal Sutherland and written by James Schmerer.

    The story involves the discovery of a man who was supposed to be dead named Carter Winston. All is not as it appears to be as the alien who has taken it’s form leads them into the Neutral Zone and into a dire confrontation with the Romulans. The crew must outsmart it and stop it before the Federation plans can get to the Romulans.

The Pros: The Romulans – The Romulans use an exiled shape-shifting Vendorian to get them the Enterprise and all the knowledge on the ship. They do a good job and almost succeed but in the end their worry about hurting the Vendorain keeps them from doing more damage to the Enterprise. This showed them as noble which I liked though their plan never felt fully fleshed out.

Captain Kirk and Spock – Kirk and Spock are great in this as the outsmart their opponent and force it to make a choice to defend the ship as well as calling the Romulans bluff which leads to the crew surviving and getting out of the Neutral Zone.

The Vendorian – The Vendorians have a great design! They look like a giant jellyfish and are pretty dangerous. I like the fact that they can shape-shift but wish they’d been fleshed out more. Still, this is a species I want to see again.

The Battle – The Battle is pretty great! 2 on 1 with Enterprise being sabotaged from within. The Romulans feel like a threat and nearly win and it is only from Kirk and Spock’s quick planning that force the Vendorian to make a choice and change sides.

Okay: Carter Winston and Anne Nored – This relationship doesn’t feel real and ends up being cliche. Nored sees past the alien whose form her husband took and she doesn’t shoot it and gets to stand guard over him at the end and the alien falls in love with her because of the form of it’s host. This would work better if it established the Vendorians took on more than just the appearance of another.

The Ending – The Vendorian decides that it will stand trial before the Federation because it is what Carter Winston would do and he was inspired by the man he took care of before he died. This would work a lot better if not for the question of why he was working for the Romulans? This makes it feel very incomplete.

   This was a good episode but not great. As stated above there was so much more that could have been explored. Why was the Vendorian exiled from his Species and how did the Romulans get it to join them? How did being Carter Winston change him? Who was Carter Winston? What did the Romulans want in the end? These are all questions that remain unclear by episodes end, though the journey here is a lot of fun.

Final Score: 8 / 10