“Kill the Moon” is an episode that really shows how cold the Doctor can be, and just how much he can take his companions, and humanity for granted. If he faced no consequences for that this episode I’d be rating it pretty low, but thankfully Clara calls him out on what he puts her and others through this time around. This episode he’s up there with the cruelty of the 9th and 10th Doctor though thankfully not up there with the 6th Doctor, or I’d stop watching the show.
The episode was written by Peter Harness and directed by Paul Wilmhurst. Both do a pretty good job this episode.
The premise is Clara is angry at the Doctor for telling Courtney she wasn’t special so the Doctor decides to make Courtney special by taking her to the Moon in 2049. The three of them are there with the last astronauts who are going to destroy it after a Mexican mining base was completely wiped out. From here the story unfolds as the creatures begin picking off the crew one by one and the truth of the Moon is revealed presenting humanity with a dilemma. From here the story unfolds.
Here is the assessment of the episode:
The Pros: Courtney Woods – She is a a student and acts like it, from posting pics on tumblr of her adventure on the moon, to her fear in the face of the Moon Spiders. She holds her own though and is the one who accidentally finds out how to kill them with Windex. She is grateful to the Doctor in the end and doesn’t realize just how badly they were used and put into a situation that they never asked to be put in. In that way she offers the naive companion perspective which Clara discards by the end of the episode.
Lundvik – Played by Hermione Norris, she’s the military astronaut coming with the nukes to destroy the Moon. It is realizing the truth of the moon and Courtney and Clara who help her change her mind. She also doesn’t put up with the Doctor’s crap and ignores him at the end. She adds humanity to a difficult role and her loss of her crew is huge as she recites the reality of the grandson that one of them just had before the mission. She feels what the Doctor is unable to feel.
Danny Pink – Appears briefly at the end to comfort Clara and be there for her after the using the Doctor did. He also asks her to find a calm place in first to make the final decision and tell him about it as he knew from his own experience that being angry at someone means you are still thinking of them.
The Premise – The premise really is amazing, and pretty well executed. An innocent creature that has destroyed lives is hatching with unintended consequences and humanity has to decide what it wants to be. This is a great idea that we saw in “Torchwood: Children of Earth” and “Fire’s of Pompeii” in “Doctor Who,” and a few others. It’s an idea that deserves constant exploration as new dilemmas are presented.
The Doctor – I hated the Doctor this episode, and I think I was supposed to. He transports Clara and Courtney to a life and death situation and leaves them there to decide the moral fate of human kind on weather an innocent baby whose parasites have been killing all humans on the moon should live or die…not knowing if it will cost humanity. He tells them it isn’t his Moon, it his Earth…it’s theirs so their choice. This is wrong given he put them in the situation in the first place and this moral choice is one he’s ignored on countless occasions. I got the feeling he did it a lot this episode to teach a lesson when the lesson was never asked for. This is the most selfish we’ve seen this Doctor and pays the price for it when Clara leaves him at episodes end. He is as cold as the 10th Doctor taking away Donna’s choice to die or 9th torturing a Dalek. He doesn’t get it in the end either which means before he finds Gallifrey, he’s got to find himself and be a good man or at least try to be like he was prior in the season. He uses people and is their officer in battlefields he chooses. He’s cold and distant, the oncoming storm for both the people he cares about and his enemies. He’s the Doctor.
Clara – Clara is one of my favorite companions after this episode. She stands up to the Doctor and leaves him and if they travel again before she officially leaves she has got to set up boundaries. The Doctor has always taken advantage of his companions and that has got to stop. They aren’t his soldiers, they’re supposed to be his friends. Clara’s calling him out was the best scene of the film as well as her decision to ignore Earth along with Lundvik and Courtney to let the creature live. I wish we could have had this happen more with Smith’s 11th Doctor as he never got called out on much at all. The only other person who did this was Donna, it is good to know Clara has Donna-like qualities in facing the Doctor’s using of people and taking her and humanity for granted.
The Cons: Execution of Premise – The moon being an egg is an interesting idea, but the Moon Spiders as parasites felt lazy. They were never fully dealing with the creature being born as a threat until the very end with the moon breaking apart so it could hatch. The parasites were just there. It gave an “Alien” feel to it that clashed at the end with the creature is good, which we’ve gotten a lot now. When are we going to see a bad complex alien that isn’t one of the Classics like Daleks or Cybermen?
This was a great episode that I highly recommend. It gives a moral dilemma and has consequences come from it as the Doctor finally has to face how much of a sociopath he is being to those around him and that his using people without their consent has consequences. I can’t wait to see what those consequences will be so he can grow up. If Clara did what needed to be done and stood up for herself, which we haven’t seen a companion do in a long time. Even with the premise not as well executed as it could be, it is still a favorite.
Final Score: 8.6 / 10