“Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness” is a good but flawed film. I appreciate Sam Raimi bringing his horror camp charm and darker tone to the MCU but the script needed more focus as it has a few issues on what it didn’t address and bring up, though it does have a core character arc for Doctor Strange, which along with the action made it a good film for me. Knowing this, if you are a Sam Raimi fan, you will find things to like here and though the multiverse isn’t made the most of, it is still explored in some fascinating ways.
The film was directed by Sam Raimi and written by Michael Waldron.
Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) must protect America Chavez (Xochitl Gomez) as she is being hunted across the multiverse for her power to jump through the multiverse.
SPOILERS ahead
The Pros:
The Action – There are some great action scenes in this film. Whether is Wanda against the Illuminati or any time Doctor Strange faces off against a monster or duel you can feel the weight of the actions and the scene has consequence. Raimi’s action game clearly hasn’t lessened since his “Spider-Man Trilogy.”
The Multiverse – What we get of the multiverse I really liked. Whether it was Defender Strange at the beginning, the destroyed universe from two that had slammed together with Sinister Strange or the Illuminati universe of Earth-838. All had a distinct feel to them and we got to experience some of the stranger worlds like an animated and a paint world in a sequence of the Ancient One pushed Doctor Strange’s mind through different realities. It was nice seeing the multiverse again in the MCU post “What If…?” and “Loki.”
The Tone – This is one of the darker MCU films and it works really well as it keeps a feel of tension throughout the entire film. There were only a few times where the tone felt broke and not in the horror or camp Raimi feel with standouts being a fight with music and any scene with Wanda in full Scarlet Witch mode or Doctor Strange pushing the limits of his magic.
Wong – Benedict Wong’s Wong continues to be one of the best parts of the MCU and a fun Sorcerer Supreme. Here we see his leading the sorcerers against the Scarlet Witch’s assault against them as she attempts to chase America Chavez for her powers. He later Scarlet Witch to the Darkhold and is key to her defeat. His dry wit plays off Strange really well.
Doctor Strange – Doctor Strange is the center of this film as the most variants we meet are Doctor Strange variants and because of this the Illuminati see him as the only true threat to the multiverse and we see later when Sinister Strange caused an “incursion” which is when 2 universes collide and are destroyed. Over the course of the film Doctor strange learns to trust and count on others and realizes why he and Christine never would have ended up together. It is a good arc and I liked how the multiverse conflict was used to explore it.
Wanda Maximoff / The Scarlet Witch – Wanda is the villain in this as she has been consumed by the Darkhold which has lead her to believe she can be with her children again by possessing another Wanda where her children are real and with America Chavez’s powers forever protect them. It is fascinating as she is both vulnerable and scary as a villain as we see just how powerful she has become and the ends she is willing to go to to achieve those ends as the Scarlet Witch. In the end it is a variant of her children being horrified by who she has become that changes her and she destroys the Darkhold in all realities, sacrificing herself in the process. Olsen is amazing in all the scenes she is in and really made a great villain.
Okay:
The Illuminati – In Earth-838 we meet the Illuminati that the Doctor Strange in their universe formed. They are Patrick Stewart as Professor X, John Krasinski as Mr. Fantastic, Lashana Lynch as Captain Marvel, Anson Mount as Black Bolt and Chiwetel Ejiofor as Baron Mordo. Great casting all around and them being afraid of all versions of Doctor Strange as they killed theirs for using the Darkhold to defeat Thanos is fascinating. I put them down as only okay though as that is all we get as they are killed off by Wanda shortly after and only the Mordo of the Illuminati survives.
America Chavez – America Chavez is okay but her character isn’t any more complex beyond getting confidence in herself to use her power to punch through the multiverse. She isn’t a bad character but there needed to be more to make the character a pro.
The Cons:
The Jokes – This film would be rated higher if the jokes weren’t so annoying. At one point Doctor Strange is just quipping at the Illuminati and felt off given the seriousness of everything that had happened up to that point. Less jokes or sticking to Raimi camp horror humor would have made the film great.
The Love Story – I never believed Christine and Doctor Strange cared about each other more than friends so the love story that is one of the central parts of Strange’s arc didn’t work for me. It just took up space in the story.
Missing Prime Mordo – So Mordo’s whole point is to destroy those who abuse magic at the end of “Doctor Strange” but he isn’t around in this at all and we had the Scarlet Witch and events of “WandaVision.” We had a Mordo so why not use the Mordo who actually has a relationship with Doctor Strange?
Lack of Quicksilver and Vision – Wanda has the infinite possibilities of the multiverse and she wasn’t looking for a world where she’d have Quicksliver and Vision as well as her children? Given how core both characters were in “WandaVision” it felt weird how they weren’t part of Wanda’s motives at all in the infinite multiversal possibilities.
The Final Scene and First After-Credits Scene – The last scene was bad. Strange randomly screams as his third eye opens and later Charlize Theron playing the sorceress Clea says he is responsible for a universal incursion and opens up a portal to the Dark Dimension. All of this felt pointless and Clea opens the portal to the Dark Dimension in a public crowded area. Both scenes felt like crazy events for the sake of crazy events while not having a point. We don’t even know what the point of the third eye is in the MCU as it is never explained nor is who the character Clea is.
This was a really good but flawed film that is well worth checking out if you like the multiverse concept and how Marvel has explored it so far or are a Sam Raimi fan. In these ways the film is strongest even though there were important details left out in the plot that kept it from reaching the levels of great. I am curious where the story will go from here and hope the whole incursion post-credits scene actually means something going forward and isn’t just dropped.
Final Score: 8.6 / 10 Flawed but good.