I still enjoy the “The Amazing Spider-Man” in the rewatch. This isn’t a good movie but it is a movie that has so much going for it in how it adapts Spider-Man differently. It is in that difference in adaptation that it gets away from Raimi’s Trilogy and is strongest when it is telling a complete story and having a clear voice. It is really in the pacing, setup of future ideas and the final action that it falls apart and isn’t good. Still worth checking out though. It is better than “Spider-Man 3.”
The film was directed by Marc Webb and written by Alvin Sargent, James Vanderbilt and Steve Cloves.
Peter Parker (Andrew Garfield) finds himself bitten by a mutant spider after following up the mystery at Oscorp behind why his parents left.
SPOILERS ahead
The Pros:
The Cinematography – John Schwartzman’s cinematography is beautiful in this. The darkness sets the theme but the suit still stands out and as the shots become brighter over the course of the film it captures the theme of Peter going from vengeance to responsibility.
The Soundtrack – I loved James Horner’s score in this It has elements of Elfman’s gothic themes which fits how isolated and dark this Peter’s perspective initially is. It shows how the bite wasn’t fun for Peter and he didn’t know what to do after it and we get his wonder when he finally finds his purpose.
The Stan Lee Cameo – Stan Lee is a librarian in Peter’s school who is listening to music as Spider-Man and Lizard fight in the background. I think this might be my favorite of his cameos. It adds such quirky humor to the scene.
The Characters – I liked the majority of the characters in this and the performances help add empathy and nuance to the roles. No standout minor characters like in the Raimi Trilogy but all the supporting cast is strong and if they aren’t a pro it is a fault of the writing.
Uncle Ben and Aunt May – Sally Fields and Martin Sheen are a great Aunt May and Uncle Ben. We spend a lot more time with them in this film and see how close they were to Peter’s parents. They are exasperated with Peter most of the time as he forgets to help around the house but it is there belief in him that helps Peter find balance and hope again.
Captain Stacey – Denis Leary is great as the grumpy cop dad who comes around to respect Peter and Spider-Man. He works as a secondary antagonist turned ally by the end and his telling Peter not to stay with Gwen fit the ghost of Uncle Ben trope in all of Peter’s relationships. He’s got a solid character arc and a great performance by Leary.
Gwen Stacey – Emma Stone is the all-star of this film and continues the trend of being one of the best and one of my favorite Spider-Men characters in film whether it is “Spider-Man 3” or “Into the Spider-Verse.” Emma Stone’s Gwen has her own dreams and goals and works at Oscorp already. She is the one to stop Lizard’s plan by making the cure and she saves Peter from Lizard when he attacks their school. I like that in the end Peter respects her choice of wanting to be with him. It was earned and her dad shouldn’t make her choices for her.
Peter Parker / Spider-Man – I was initially annoyed with this version of Peter as being too much like “Batman Begins” but rewatching years later I’ve come appreciate it. Peter Parker has always had anger issues and Garfield does intensity so well. He also isn’t as secret as Maguire which bests his version apart as he tells Gwen he’s Spider-Man early. I respected that and loved his arc of going from vengeance to responsibility and hope.
The Gwen and Peter Partnership – Gwen and Peter help each other on multiple occasions. She covers for him when he sneaks into Oscorp and later helps him fight the Lizard a few times. She is his partner in the adventure and I love it.
Vengeance to Responsibility – After Uncle Ben’s murder Peter is on a vendetta hunt where he never finds the guy. What changes is his perspective though as Captain Stacey calls out Spider-Man and Peter realizes he helped make the Lizard with his father’s equation to Dr. Connors. After he saves a kid he becomes a protector and stops being a punisher. It is an arc that works.
Uncle Ben’s Last Voicemail – Uncle Ben’s voicemail is powerful and is a much better responsibility speech than the one he gives when he’s alive. It is sad and powerful and motivates Peter to heal and continue his relationship to Gwen.
Okay:
Dr. Curt Connors / The Lizard – Rhys Ifans gives a good performance as Peter’s mentor and possible friend and threat as the Lizard. Sadly the Lizard personality is not presented very well. We don’t get the separation done as clearly as with Green Goblin. This keeps him from being good as his Lizard motives are vague and ill-defined and his core relationship with Peter’s dad and in turn Peter is never fully flshed out. The idea of it is good but like the CGI of Lizard, isn’t always good on execution. Still okay due to the performance.
The Cons:
The Pacing – This film drags in a few places. When Peter gets his powers it goes on a little long and could have been cut shorter and same goes for most of the fights though I really liked the sewer fight. They didn’t need to be as long and in the case of the final fight it hurt the overall film.
Uncle Ben’s Death – The scene and writing in the shop where the thief Peter lets go happens is so poorly written. It makes the death hurt too as it feels as clunky as the scene prior and in the end we never see the thief again. Uncle Ben’s death should be the most powerfully written scene and here it failed on every level.
The Final Fight – It is overlong, gas over New York City and a special effect over Oscorp and shows how bad the Lizard looks as a special effect. Wasn’t a fan. The other fights with Lizard were perfectly paced and much better.
The Parker Parents Mystery – A mystery figure says if Dr. Curt Connors told Peter the truth about his parents and Connors says to leave him alone. This is dumb as pulling things back to the parents detracts from everything else. It is just a “mystery box” and it was one that didn’t payoff later.
This was a film that missed the mark on some important moments like Uncle Ben’s death and the final fight but worked in the core relationships and performances. Emma Stone is amazing in this as Gwen Stacey and Garfield’s interpretation of Peter Parker works. I’m not looking forward to reviewing “The Amazing Spider-Man 2” but this film still holds up and I do recommend.
Final Score: 7.6 / 10